Building Trust by Supporting Situation Awareness: Exploring Pilots' Design Requirements for Decision Support Tools

Cara Storath, Zelun Tony Zhang, Yuanting Liu and Heinrich Hußmann

CHI TRAIT '22: Workshop on Trust and Reliance in Human-AI Teams at CHI 2022,

April 2022

abstract

Supporting pilots with a decision support tool (DST) during high-workload scenarios is a promising and potentially very helpful application for AI in aviation. Nevertheless, design requirements and opportunities for trustworthy DSTs within the aviation domain have not been explored much in the scientific literature. To address this gap, we explore the decision-making process of pilots with respect to user requirements for the use case of diversions. We do so via two prototypes, each representing a role the AI could have in a DST: A) Unobtrusively hinting at data points the pilot should be aware of. B) Actively suggesting and ranking diversion options based on criteria the pilot has previously defined. Our work-in-progress feedback study reveals four preliminary main findings: 1) Pilots demand guaranteed trustworthiness of such a system and refuse trust calibration in the moment of emergency. 2) We may need to look beyond trust calibration for isolated decision points and rather design for the process leading to the decision. 3) An unobtrusive, augmenting AI seems to be preferred over an AI proposing and ranking diversion options at decision time. 4) Shifting the design goal toward supporting situation awareness rather than the decision itself may be a promising approach to increase trust and reliance.

subject terms: human-AI interaction, decision support tools, decision support systems, human-AI teaming, aviation

url: https://chi-trait.github.io/papers/CHI_TRAIT_2022_Paper_19.pdf